Skip to content

Compliance penetration testing for financial firms

Federal and state rules now expect many ordinary financial businesses to run a penetration test. This guide shows owners of brokerages, lenders, tax shops and agencies who is covered, what the rules ask for in plain terms, and how one yearly test plus a maintenance plan satisfies them.

Do regulators really require a penetration test now?

For a large group of financial businesses, yes. The FTC Safeguards Rule and the New York DFS cybersecurity regulation both name penetration testing as part of keeping customer data safe. Neither rule is aimed only at banks. Both reach mortgage brokers, lenders, tax preparers, agencies and other firms that most people would not call a bank.

The shift is recent. The FTC made its testing requirement enforceable on June 9, 2023, under 16 CFR 314.4(d). New York tightened its rule in a Second Amendment effective November 1, 2023, under 23 NYCRR 500.5. If your business handles customer financial information, one or both of these rules probably applies to you.

The good news: the rules describe an outcome, not a brand of test or a license. They want proof that someone competent attacked your systems and that you fixed what they found. That is exactly what Grapefruit delivers, at a fixed price, with the report in about 10 days.

Who counts as a financial institution?

Far more businesses than the name suggests. The FTC Safeguards Rule defines a financial institution broadly under 16 CFR 314.2(h), and the rule and FTC guidance name a long list of everyday businesses. If you lend, finance, broker, prepare taxes, collect debts or move money, you are likely covered even without the word bank on your door.

New York draws its own line under 23 NYCRR 500.1: anyone operating under a license, registration or charter under the state's Banking Law, Insurance Law or Financial Services Law. A mortgage broker licensed in New York can sit under both rules at once.

  • Mortgage brokers and mortgage lenders.
  • Auto dealers that finance or lease vehicles.
  • Tax preparers.
  • Payday, installment and other non-bank lenders, plus finance companies.
  • Collection agencies.
  • Check cashers and money transmitters.
  • Investment advisers and credit counselors.
  • Insurance agencies and producers, especially those licensed in New York.

What do the two main rules require?

Each rule asks for annual penetration testing by a competent, qualified party, plus regular scanning of your systems. The FTC gives you a choice: either continuously monitor your systems, or do both an annual penetration test and vulnerability assessments at least every six months. New York requires annual testing from inside and outside your network and ties scan frequency to your own risk assessment.

The table below sums up who each rule covers and what it asks for. The practical takeaway is the same for both: one real test a year, plus recurring scans, with a record you can show an examiner.

RuleWho it coversWhat it requires
FTC Safeguards Rule, 16 CFR 314.4(d)Non-bank financial businesses: brokers, lenders, dealers, tax preparers, collectors, money transmittersContinuous monitoring, or both annual penetration testing and vulnerability assessments at least every six months
NY DFS, 23 NYCRR 500.5New York licensees under Banking, Insurance or Financial Services LawPenetration testing at least annually from inside and outside the network, plus scans at a frequency set by the risk assessment

What is the 5,000-consumer exemption?

The FTC Safeguards Rule exempts the smallest firms from the testing requirement. Under 16 CFR 314.6, a business that maintains customer information on fewer than 5,000 consumers is exempt from the testing provision and a few others. Cross 5,000 and the full testing requirement applies to you.

That line is easy to trip over. Consumer counts add up across years of old files, not just this year's active clients. If you have served thousands of borrowers or filed thousands of returns over time, you are probably over the line and inside the rule. When you are close, the safe read is that testing applies.

New York uses different thresholds, covered on the NY DFS page. A firm can be exempt from one rule and covered by the other, so check both.

How does New York differ from the FTC rule?

New York requires testing from both inside and outside your network and ties scan frequency to your risk assessment, while the FTC offers an either-or path and names a six-month scan cadence. New York does not set a six-month scan rule. It asks for automated scans plus manual review at a frequency your own risk assessment defines, and after any material change.

New York also exempts small entities on different terms. Under 23 NYCRR 500.19, a covered entity is exempt from the testing requirement if it meets any one of three thresholds: fewer than 20 employees and contractors, under 7.5 million dollars in gross annual revenue from New York operations in each of the last three years, or under 15 million dollars in year-end total assets.

If you are licensed in New York and also handle customer financial data, read both rule pages. The NY DFS page covers 500.5 and the exemption thresholds in full.

Do you need a licensed tester or a certification?

No. There is no US penetration-testing license, and neither rule names a certification. The FTC asks for a competent tester. New York asks for a qualified internal or external party. Both care that the person doing the work knows what they are doing, not that they hold a particular badge.

What the law does require is permission. Testing a system without authorization is a federal crime under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 U.S.C. 1030. That is why Grapefruit takes a signed testing authorization and a defined scope before any test runs. You verify your domain, sign online, and the authorized test begins.

How does one yearly test plus a plan satisfy the rule?

The rules have two halves, and Grapefruit maps onto both. The annual penetration test is one Grapefruit full test a year. The recurring scanning half is a Grapefruit maintenance plan, which re-tests your verified domains every week or month, well inside the six-month line and dated for your file. One full test a year plus a Grapefruit maintenance plan covers both halves of the rule.

Every finding arrives with the exact request and response that proves it, ranked critical, high, medium or low in your portal. Your engineer replays the request, fixes the issue, and replays it to watch the attack fail. The dated before and after is the remediation evidence an examiner wants to see.

  • Annual half: one full penetration test at a fixed quote, report in about 10 days.
  • Recurring half: a maintenance plan re-testing weekly or monthly, each run dated in the portal.
  • Every finding carries captured request and response evidence you can replay.
  • A dated trail of new and fixed findings, ready for an FTC or DFS examiner.
  • App, API and AI features attacked together in one test, because real attacks chain across them.

What is the fastest way to find out if you are covered?

Run the compliance check. Answer a few questions about your business, your consumer count and your state, and it tells you which rule applies and what it asks of you. It takes a minute and points you to the full test, a plan, or both.

From there, setup is quick. Add your hostname, publish one DNS TXT record, and sign the testing authorization online. Testing starts right after, using test accounts you supply for authenticated coverage. Pick a full penetration test at a fixed quote, or a maintenance plan with public pricing and card checkout. See pricing to compare. This is a summary of public rules, not legal advice.

Questions

Does my brokerage really need a penetration test?
Most likely, yes. If you handle customer financial information and serve 5,000 or more consumers, the FTC Safeguards Rule requires either continuous monitoring or an annual penetration test plus six-month scans. If you are licensed in New York, 23 NYCRR 500.5 requires annual testing on its own terms. Run the compliance check to confirm which rule covers you.
Is there a penetration-testing license I should look for?
No. There is no US penetration-testing license, and neither the FTC Safeguards Rule nor the New York DFS regulation names a certification. The FTC asks for a competent tester and New York for a qualified party. What matters is skill and a signed authorization, since testing without permission is a crime under 18 U.S.C. 1030.
I am a small shop. Am I exempt?
Maybe. The FTC exempts firms that maintain customer information on fewer than 5,000 consumers under 16 CFR 314.6, but that count adds up across years of files. New York exempts small entities under 23 NYCRR 500.19 on separate thresholds. You can be exempt from one rule and covered by the other, so check both before assuming you are out.
How often do I have to test for compliance?
Both rules center on annual testing. The FTC path also asks for vulnerability assessments at least every six months unless you continuously monitor. New York ties scan frequency to your risk assessment and after material changes. One full Grapefruit test a year plus a maintenance plan that re-tests weekly or monthly covers both the annual and the recurring half.
How does Grapefruit prove the test happened for my file?
Each test and re-test is dated and kept in your portal, with every finding ranked by severity and backed by the captured request and response. When a finding is fixed, a later run shows it gone. That dated trail of findings and fixes is the evidence an FTC or DFS examiner expects to see.
How fast can I get tested and hold a report?
Setup takes a few minutes: add your hostname, publish one DNS TXT record, sign the authorization online. Testing starts right after and the report lands in about 10 days at a fixed price. There is no demo call and no scheduling, so you can move from covered-and-unsure to report-in-hand well inside a planning cycle.

Standards and sources